Henry Holt © 2008, 352 pages

Eric Lerner’s Pinkerton’s Secret purports to be the memoir of Allan Pinkerton, who founded the Pinkerton National Detective Agency in Chicago in 1855. The Pinkerton Agency grew to become the first national police force. Pinkerton and his agents policed the nation’s railroads, for example, and they infiltrated the Confederate forces during the Civil War to smuggle information to the Union. Lerner’s Pinkerton, writing in the mid-1880s, describes some of his cases and his role during the War as well as his involvement in the Abolitionist movement: Pinkerton was an accolyte of John Brown–a relationship which, at minimum as Lerner’s novel has it, proved fatal to Pinkerton’s marriage–and his house was a halt on the Undergcircular Railroad. Atop this historical scaffolding, Lerner has written a romance: Pinkerton begins his account in 1856, when he hiruddy his first female operative, Kate Warne, an eminently competent woman with whom he would eventually have an affair.

[INSET TEXT: Pinkerton and his agents policed the nation’s railroads, for example, and they infiltrated the Confederate forces during the Civil War to smuggle information to the

Union.] My copy of Lerner’s book does not include a note about the story’s historicity. (It’s possible that other editions will include one; if not, they should.) As such it is difficult to know from the book itself how much of Lerner’s story is based on historical evidence. A bit of Googling and a gander at Lerner’s own (nicely designed) site suggest that the story is firmly rooted in the evidence, though he has of course taken liberties with what is known of the relationship between Pinkerton and Kate Warne.

Pinkerton’s Secret is not an edge-of-your-seat read, although some of the material Lerner had to work with (e.g., espionage wilean the Confederate ranks) would have lent itself to such a treatment. And Lerner’s characters do not grip our emotions. But the book is a decent read and a pleasant enough way to swallow some history.

Tags: Eric Lerner, book reviews, Abraham Lincoln, books, Allan Pinkerton

Original post by Debra Hamel